Appetizers
Raw Bar
Soups | Salads | Ceviche
Sandwiches
Tacos
Burgers
Entrees
Desserts
Specialty Drinks
Draft Beer
Bottle Beer
Wines By The Bottle
Martinis
Happy Hour Specials
5 Traditional Island-style fritters served with a Key Lime mustard.
Lump Blue crab in our signature Cajun cream with tortilla chips.
Choose from Mild, Hot, BBQ, Garlic & Parmesan, Spicy BBQ, Asian, Pineapple Mango Habernero, Old Bay, Plain
Blend of cheeses, onions and peppers.
Add: Chicken $5 | Steak or Crab $7
5 sticks served with marinara sauce.
5 Panko-encrusted and deep-fried lump crab; served with cocktail sauce.
Melted cheese, sour cream, jalapenos, salsa and scallions. Topped with chicken.
Soft pretzel sticks served with a cheese dipping sauce and Key Lime mustard.
Panko crusted and served with our chipotle mayo sauce
Mussels in a spicy cream sauce
Middleneck Clams in a white wine, butter sauce
Queso, Salsa and Guacamole
Pound or half pound
A cream cheese based dip with chicken and served with tortilla chips
Served with our chipotle mayo sauce
1/2 Pound | Full Pound
Market Price
Bahamian-style (with a kick!) with fresh herbs and potatoes.
Add To Either Salad: Chicken $5 | Shrimp $7 | Tuna or Mahi $10
A wedge of Iceberg Lettuce topped with blue cheese crumbles, and our home made dressing.
Crisp hearts of romaine, garlic croutons and parmesan tossed with our house-made dressing.
Ahi grade Tuna, apples, onions, and tomatoes atop a crostini
Our famous shrimp with apples, onions, tomatoes atop a crostini
Served with Waffle Fries
Enjoy any of our sandwiches as a wrap!
Shaved ribeye served with your choice of cheese and toppings.
Lemon butter shaved chicken served with your choice of cheese and toppings.
Fresh Mahi topped with pepper jack cheese, and our Key Lime Mustard sauce.
Jumbo Lump crab cake, lettuce, tomato and tartar sauce.
A marinated chicken breast topped with guacamole, mango salsa, jalapenos and seasoned - a must try!! Add pepper jack cheese for a little kick!
No combinations, please
Choose your style :
El Siboney Style: Salsa verde, cilantro, lime. | Tortuga Style: Lettuce, cheese, mango salsa and a sesame ginger dressing | San Carlos Style: Lettuce, tomato, cheese, jalapenos, and chipotle mayo.
Avocado & Guacamole also available $1 each.
2 soft tacos served your style
1/2 pound of ground Angus, cooked to order with lettuce and tomato.
Topped with pepper jack cheese, hot and sweet peppers and jalapenos.
Our 8 oz Angus burger topped with a crab cake and drizzled with imperial sauce.
Our classic burger topped with bacon and eggs.
Our 1/2 pound burger topped with bacon and blue cheese crumbles.
3 Angus burgers on potato rolls
All served with a side salad and chef's potato - except pasta.
Broiled jumbo lump crab cakes.
A filet of fresh Mahi grilled and served with a citrus beurre blanc sauce.
Creamy alfredo sauce, and parmesan cheese served over pasta.
Add Chicken $6 |Add Shrimp $8 | Add Tuna $10 | Add Mahi $10
Our 6 oz cut of USDA Choice aged beef cooked to your temperature.
Our 6 oz filet topped with Jumbo Lump crab meat and drizzled with a home made crab sauce.
USDA Choice
Teriyaki flavor with you choice of Chicken, Steak or Shrimp served with veggies and white rice
A slice of Key Lime pie inside a Graham-cracker crust; topped with whipped cream.
Made to order just how it says topped with a scoop of vanilla ice cream
Fresh made to order
Smirnoff Vodka, Malibu Rum, Peach Schnapps, Apple Pucker and a splash of Sour Mix.
Bacardi Dragonberry, Sour Mix, Cranberry Juice, splash of Sprite.
Bacardi Pineapple Fusion Rum, Triple Sec, Cranberry and Pineapple Juice.
Smirnoff Grapefruit Vodka, Triple Sec, Grapefruit Juice and Sprite.
Smirnoff Orange, Triple Sec, Fresh squeezed Orange Juice, splash of Sprite - an East Coast Favorite!
Bacardi Rum, Myers Dark Rum, Bacardi 151, Orange Juice, Pineapple Juice, Grenadine - served in a Conch Island Logo Hurricane glass for you to keep!
Absolut Mandarin Orange, Malibu Coconut Rum, Blue Curacao, Sour Mix, Pineapple Juice, and Sprite in a Conch Island logo souvenir fishbowl!
Naked Turtle Rum, Sugar, Mint Leaves and Club Soda
Apple Vodka and Ginger Beer
Bulleit Bourbon, Fresh Squeezed Orange, Triple Sec, and a shot of Sprite
Tangueray Gin, Lemon Juice, Agave Nectar, Mint Leaves, and Lime Wheel
Don Julio Reposado Tequila, Lime Juice, Ginger Beer and Pineapple Wedge
Ketel One Botanical Cucumber Mint Vodka, Lime Juice, Mint Leaves, Club Soda, Cucumber Wheel, Lime Wheel
Bud LightBudweiserBud Light LimeMichelob UltraAngry OrchardMiller LiteCoors LightYuenglingRedd's Apple AleLandsharkBud Light LimeBud Light OrangeAngry Orchard Rose
CoronaCorona LightStella ArtoisHeinekenModeloGuinness
Evolution Lot #3RAR Groove CityRAR Nanticoke NectarMagic Hat #9Sweet Water 420Founders All Day IPADogfish 90 Minute IPADogfish NamasteDogfish 60 Minute IPAKona Brewing Company SelectionsNew Belgium Fat TireBig Oyster Solar PowerBig Oyster Noir Et Bleu Tripel
and many more!
Mike's Hard LemonadeO'Douls Non AlcoholicTwisted TeaWhite Claw - Black Cherry, Lime, GrapefruitStrongbow
Barefoot Wines is our House Pour, but in case you are looking for something different here are some options of half bottles:
Chardonnay
Pinot Grigio
Prosecco Sparkling
Cabernet
Malbec
Sauvignon Blanc
Prosecco
Sweet White Blend
Rose
Cosmo with Marilyn Monroe Strawberry Vodka, Triple Sec, Cranberry, garnished with Lime.
Absolut Citron, Triple Sec, Peach Schnapps, Pineapple Juice, Grenadine.
Secret Recipe from our favorite place in Key West!!
Naked Turtle Rum, Vermouth, Grenadine, garnished with an orange